Motivated Seller Ads: What Actually Works on Google, Facebook and YouTube

Running ads to find motivated sellers is simple to describe and easy to do badly. The platforms are Google, Facebook and Instagram, and YouTube. Each one reaches a homeowner at a different point in their thinking, and the ad that works on one will usually fail on another.

We spend roughly $15 million a year running exactly these campaigns for real estate investors. This is what the spend has taught us, including the mistakes that quietly waste most of a new advertiser’s budget.

The three platforms do different jobs

Google captures demand that already exists. Somebody typing “sell my house fast for cash” has decided something. That is why the clicks are expensive, often $30 or more in competitive markets, and why the leads convert best.

Facebook creates demand. Nobody opens Instagram intending to sell their house. You are interrupting them with a proposition, which makes leads cheaper and softer. Facebook lead volume with weak follow-up is the most common way investors conclude that paid ads do not work.

YouTube sits between the two and is the most underused of the three for this niche.

What the ad should say

Seller ads fail on the offer far more often than on targeting. The homeowner is deciding between listing with an agent and selling to you, so the ad has to answer why they would take less money.

The reasons that work, in roughly this order:

• Speed. A specific closing window beats “fast” every time. “Close in 14 days” outperforms “we buy houses fast” consistently.
• Certainty. No financing contingency, no appraisal, no deal falling through three weeks in.
• Condition. They do not have to repair, clean, or show the house. For a property they are embarrassed by, this is often the whole reason.
• No fees. No commission, no closing costs, no contents to clear.

Keep the language plain. Investor jargon such as ARV, assignment or off market means nothing to a homeowner and quietly signals that the ad is not for them.

The form is where most budgets are lost

More motivated seller campaigns are ruined by the landing page than by the ads. Three rules hold up across every account we have run:

1. Ask for the address first, not the phone number. Address is a low commitment question about the house. Phone number is a high commitment question about them. Leading with the phone number measurably reduces completions.
2. Keep it to one question per screen. A multi step form with a visible progress bar consistently outperforms one long form, because each step is a small yes.
3. Do not ask anything you will not use. Every optional field costs completions. If you are not going to act on the answer, remove it.

Then the part that matters more than all of it: contact speed. Sellers who fill in a cash offer form usually fill in several. Responding in five minutes rather than five hours changes conversion more than any targeting change you can make.

Tracking, and the mistake almost everyone makes

The default setup optimises for form fills. That is the wrong target. The platform will happily find you a large number of people who fill in forms and never answer the phone, because that is exactly what you asked for.

What to do instead:

• Capture the click identifiers on the form. Google passes gclid, gbraid and wbraid. Meta passes fbclid. Store them with the lead.
• Push the outcome back. When a lead becomes a contract or a closed deal, send that event back to the platform as an offline conversion tied to the stored identifier.
• Optimise on the outcome, not the form fill. Once the platform can see which clicks became contracts, it starts finding more of those people.

This is the single highest leverage change available to most investor ad accounts, and it is the one most commonly skipped because it takes a week of plumbing rather than an afternoon.

What good numbers look like

For calibration, from campaigns we run:

• Cost per lead of roughly $100 in a typical market, higher in the most competitive metros.
• Around 1 in 17 leads becomes a contract when follow-up is genuinely in place.
• Roughly a 50 percent close rate on contracts written.
• Which lands at about $3,400 per closed deal.

Client results at the top end have run 11.67x return on ad spend on a $300,000 revenue month, and 6.97x across $755,000 in revenue. Those are not typical months, and any provider quoting only their best numbers is not showing you the range.

If you would rather not build and manage this yourself, we run the ads and send the leads. See how pay per lead works or check availability in your market.

Frequently asked questions

← Back to all articles