Inbound vs Cold Call Leads: The Real Cost Per Deal

If you are deciding whether to buy inbound pay per lead leads or cold call leads, the sticker price on the lead is the least useful number in the conversation. What matters is what a closed deal ends up costing you.

We have spent a little over $15 million on PPC, Facebook ads and SEO, we have bought plenty of cold call leads ourselves, and we have helped clients do a little over $51 million in revenue. Here is what our numbers actually say.

The cold call math

Start with a cold call lead at $75. In our experience the lead to contract ratio on cold call leads runs about one in fifty.

• $75 per lead
• 1 contract per 50 leads
• $75 x 50 = $3,750 per contract

Now apply a close rate. Most investors close about half the contracts they sign. Some good operators hit 60 or 70 percent. Plenty come in lower. Using 50 percent as a fair average, you double the contract cost.

Cost per deal on cold call leads: about $7,500.

The inbound math

Inbound leads come from PPC, SEO, YouTube, Facebook and TikTok. These are homeowners who went looking and filled out a form. Our statewide inbound leads are $100.

Across the data our clients report back to us, the inbound lead to contract ratio averages one in seventeen.

• $100 per lead
• 1 contract per 17 leads
• $100 x 17 = $1,700 per contract

Apply the same 50 percent close rate.

Cost per deal on inbound leads: about $3,400.

Side by side

	Cold call lead	Inbound lead
Cost per lead	$75	$100
Lead to contract	1 in 50	1 in 17
Cost per contract	$3,750	$1,700
Close rate	50%	50%
Cost per deal	$7,500	$3,400

The inbound lead costs 33 percent more up front and produces a deal for less than half the money.

What if the cold call lead is cheaper?

This is the objection we hear most, so run it. Say you find cold call leads at $40 instead of $75. In our experience cheaper cold call leads convert worse, not better, and you are closer to one in a hundred.

• $40 x 100 = $4,000 per contract
• 50 percent close rate
• $8,000 per deal

The cheaper lead produced a more expensive deal. That is the trap. A low price per lead tells you nothing about the cost of the outcome you actually want.

The cost nobody puts on the spreadsheet

There is a second number that never shows up in these comparisons: your time and your team’s time.

Fifty cold call leads is fifty conversations with people who did not ask to hear from you, and most of them go nowhere. Seventeen inbound leads is seventeen conversations with people who raised their hand. The phone time to get one contract is not close between the two, and if you pay a dialer team, that gap has a dollar figure attached to it.

What this means for how you buy

Inbound costs more per lead and less per deal. You pay more up front, you spend less time on the phone, and your cost per closed transaction drops by more than half.

If you are comparing lead providers, stop comparing price per lead. Ask for the lead to contract ratio, apply your own close rate, and compare cost per deal. That is the only number that pays you.

Before you buy from anyone, there are three questions worth asking. We wrote those up in how to get leads for real estate. If you want to see what exclusive inbound leads cost in your market, look at motivated seller leads by market or read how pay per lead real estate works.

← Back to all articles